How can I gain insights into rental companies when starting a vacation rental business?
September 30, 2025
12 minutes
Starting a vacation rental business brings up a big question: which rental company should you trust with your property? The decision can shape your returns, guest experience, and peace of mind. But choosing blindly or focusing only on fees often leads to poor results.
If you want to gain real insights into rental companies, you need to look beyond the sales pitch. Here’s a clear breakdown to help you understand how these companies work and what you should ask before signing a contract.
Management Models to Compare
The first insight is knowing how companies differ in their approach. Most vacation rental businesses fall into three categories:
Professional Property Management (PM)
- Full-service: bookings, guest support, cleaning, compliance, and financial reporting.
- Often raise revenue 20-30% thanks to expertise and systems.
- Strong insurance and guest screening.
- Cost: 20-50% of income. Best for owners who want a hands-off experience.
Co-Hosts
Informal managers, often focused on Airbnb only.
- Handle listings and guest communication but limited in services.
- Fees: 10-30% of income.
- Best if you want to stay involved with one property.
Self-Management
- No fees but full responsibility.
- Works only if you have time, tools, and pricing knowledge.
- Can outperform companies if done well, but riskier without systems.
What this tells you about rental companies: Look at how much support they offer. A company with robust services is not the same as a casual co-host.
Buying a Home? Get up to 1.5% Cash Back at Closing
Get pre-approval first, then start exploring homes knowing you can receive up to 1.5% of the home price back at closing.
Looking Past the Fee Percentage
Many first-time investors ask, “What do you charge?” That’s not enough. To gain insights into rental companies, focus on their net results after all costs.
Common Fee Structures
Fee Model | How It Works | Range | What It Means for You |
|---|---|---|---|
Commission | Percentage of gross income | 25–40% | Incentives align. Manager earns when you earn. |
Flat Fee | Fixed monthly charge | $100–$500 | Predictable cost if occupancy is steady. |
Guaranteed Income | Manager pays you fixed rent | $500–$2,000+ | Safe income but less upside in peak season. |
Extra Costs to Ask About
- Marketing and ads
- Cleaning charges
- Maintenance markups (10–150%)
- Linen or admin fees
What this tells you about rental companies: The headline percentage means little without the full picture. Ask about average net margins, not just fees.
Revenue Strategies as a Benchmark
A strong rental company doesn’t only clean and list your property. It should actively drive revenue.
Dynamic Pricing
- Software adjusts nightly rates based on demand, events, and seasonality.
- Tools: PriceLabs, Beyond Pricing.
- Can improve both occupancy and average nightly rate.
Distribution Across Channels
- Listings on Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com, plus direct booking sites.
- Expands guest reach and reduces platform dependence.
What this tells you about rental companies: If a manager isn’t using pricing tools or multiple channels, they’re behind the curve.
Risk and Operations Insights
Short-term rentals come with risks that only professional systems can handle.
Insurance and Compliance
- STR-specific policies are needed. Standard home insurance won’t work.
- A good company manages local laws and tax rules.
Guest Screening and Security
- Use of ID verification tools (Superhog, Authenticate).
- Tech like smart locks and noise monitoring adds safety.
Save up to 1.5% at closing when you buy
Save up to 1.5% at closing when you combine real estate and mortgage services with reAlpha.
Maintenance and Guest Experience
- Strong cleaning schedules and inspections keep reviews high.
- High reviews = more bookings.
What this tells you about rental companies: Ask how they manage risk. Companies that cut corners on compliance or guest checks put your income at risk.
Questions That Reveal Real Insights
The best way to gain insights into a rental company is by asking direct questions. Here are the essentials:
- How many STRs do you manage locally?
- What’s your client retention rate?
- Do you provide 24/7 guest support?
- What’s your exact fee model and are there hidden fees?
- How do you handle maintenance approvals and inspections?
- What pricing tools do you use?
- Can you provide references from current owners?
The answers will show whether a company is structured, experienced, and transparent-or just running listings casually.
FAQs
How do I know if a rental company is good for a first property?
Check if they offer full transparency, use modern pricing tools, and have experience with similar properties in your market.
Should I always choose the cheapest company?
No. A lower fee doesn’t mean higher profit. Compare based on net returns, not percentages.
Is self-management better for first-timers?
Only if you have time and tools. Otherwise, professional management reduces risk.
What if my market has strict STR laws?
Work with a company that specializes in compliance. They should know permits, taxes, and local regulations.
Final Takeaway
When you’re starting a vacation rental business, gaining insights into rental companies is about asking the right questions and comparing more than fees. Look at their services, revenue strategy, risk management, and track record.
The right company should feel like a partner who protects your property and grows your income. The wrong one will leave you paying fees without results.
Your next step: make a shortlist of local rental companies and interview them with these questions. The answers will tell you everything you need to know.
Ready to buy or sell smarter?
With reAlpha, you keep a significant portion of the buyer agent commission and gain access to AI-powered insights on affordability, timing, and market forecasts.
Get the latest market trends, homebuying tips, and insider updates—straight to your inbox. No fluff, just the good stuff.
Article by
As a great communicator with excellent negotiation skills, I focus more on establishing unbreakable ties between my clients, as opposed to just helping them achieve their real estate dreams. As a representative of both buyers and sellers, I understand how to lead a transaction process to ensure that the needs of both are met. My track record speaks for itself. Since I ventured into the industry in 2013 as a realtor, I have not only helped many buyers land perfect homes, but I have also assisted tons of owners and investors build wealth.